Subway is known for its fresh sandwiches and customizable options, but did you know they have a secret menu? These hidden gems are fan favorites that aren’t listed but can be ordered if you know what to ask for.

From unique sandwich cuts to nostalgic favorites, the secret menu offers something special for every Subway lover. Whether you want an extra cheesy sub or a throwback way of cutting your sandwich, there’s something exciting to try.

If you’re a true Subway enthusiast, exploring these secret menu items is a must. Let’s dive into some of the best-kept secrets you can still order today!

Subway Secret Menu

What is Subway Secret Menu?

The Subway secret menu consists of special items that aren’t advertised but can still be made by request. Some of these were once official menu options, while others are custom creations made popular by fans.

Ordering from the secret menu can enhance your Subway experience, giving you a chance to enjoy exclusive flavors and creative combinations. You only need to know the right way to order!

Subway Secret Old Cut

Old Cut Subway Secret Menu

The Old Cut is a classic way Subway used to prepare their sandwiches before switching to the modern horizontal cut. Instead of slicing the bread from the side, the Old Cut removes a V-shaped wedge from the top, creating a pocket to hold the fillings. This method helps keep the toppings in place, reducing mess.

  • Ask for the “Old Cut” instead of the standard horizontal cut.
  • Specify that you want a V-shaped cut from the top of the bread.
  • Watch closely to ensure your sandwich is made correctly.

This is a nostalgic favorite that longtime Subway fans still swear by!

Also see Subway Menu Prices

Subway Secret Pizza Sub

Pizza Sub Subway Secret Menu

The Pizza Sub is a dream come true for pizza lovers. It features pepperoni, marinara sauce, and plenty of melted cheese, creating a sandwich that tastes just like a pizza. Originally a menu item, it was discontinued in many locations, but you can still order it using Subway’s ingredients.

  • Ask for a sub with pepperoni and marinara sauce.
  • Request extra mozzarella or provolone cheese.
  • Toast it to get that gooey, melty pizza texture.

This is the perfect sub for anyone craving a pizza but wanting it in sandwich form!

Subway Secret Wing Effect

Wing Effect

The Wing Effect is a stylish way to order a Subway sandwich that makes it look more visually appealing. Instead of tucking the meat completely into the sub, some of it sticks out the sides, resembling wings. This not only enhances the look but also gives you extra meat in every bite.

  • Ask for the “Wing Effect” when ordering your sandwich.
  • Request the meat to be folded so that part of it sticks out.
  • Make sure the sandwich artist understands your request before they wrap it up.

It’s a fun and tasty way to enjoy your Subway sandwich with a little extra flair!

Also see Panera Bread Secret Menu

Trending Secret Menu Old Cut at Subway

The Old Cut has been making a strong comeback among Subway fans. Many longtime customers miss the way it used to hold fillings better, preventing spills and making the sandwich easier to eat.

With more people discovering this classic technique through social media, Subway employees are getting more requests for the Old Cut. It’s quickly becoming one of the most popular secret menu items again!

How to Get the Old Cut at Subway?

  • Be polite when asking for the Old Cut, as not all employees may know about it.
  • Explain that you want the bread cut in a V-shape from the top.
  • If the employee is unsure, show them a picture or describe the cut clearly.
  • Visit locations where experienced sandwich artists are more likely to be familiar with it.

Final Thoughts

Exploring Subway’s secret menu is a fun way to try something different from the usual offerings. Whether you’re craving a nostalgic Old Cut, a pizza-inspired sub, or a unique sandwich presentation, these hidden items add a new twist to your meal. Don’t be afraid to ask for them—you might just discover a new favorite!